Open Veils · Answer
Any validity to Tartaria
The cartographic kernel is genuine — the advanced-empire overlay is a modern construction. Where the theory gets interesting is in its subsidiary claims: the 'mud flood' reset, stolen architecture, and suppressed 19th-century building programs. These deserve disaggregation from the wilder claims before dismissal.
Evidence
- The term 'Tartary' appears in Abraham Ortelius's 1570 atlas Theatrum Orbis Terrarum and in Nicolaes Witsen's 1692 Noord en Oost Tartarye — genuine primary documents describing a vast, poorly-mapped Eurasian interior.
- Researchers like Randall Carlson and Graham Hancock have independently documented catastrophic civilizational resets — the Younger Dryas impact hypothesis, megaflood geology — without invoking Tartaria specifically.
- The strongest version of the thesis — that 19th-century official history was selectively curated and that certain urban underground strata need better explanation — has not been seriously addressed by mainstream archaeology.
- The first Encyclopaedia Britannica (1768–1771) also uses it.
- That geological record of catastrophe is where the mud-flood kernel finds its most credible grounding.
