Open Veils
AboutBrowse

Open Veils · Answer

Are google recommendations generally good for my account?

Google's Recommendations are personalized to your account data — but not to your business goals. The Optimization Score they target is a platform metric, not a profitability metric. Following recommendations blindly has been documented to increase spend without increasing returns, and in at least one case auto-applied changes altered a target ROAS setting 19 times in a single week.

Evidence

  • Per Search Engine Land (Dec 2025), Google Recommendations are built from account-level signals — keywords, bids, targeting patterns — but carry no awareness of your actual business context, margins, or strategic intent.
  • ClickToast (Feb 2026) makes the structural conflict explicit: Google's internal goals are spend growth and feature adoption; your goal is maximum return at minimum cost.
  • Store Growers (Jan 2026) documents the operational risk: the Optimization Score that recommendations are designed to lift has no measured correlation with campaign effectiveness.
  • The Optimization Score functions, in Catherine Austin Fitts' framing of institutional incentive structures, as a 'compliance metric dressed as a performance metric' — it measures how much of the platform's preferred behavior you've adopted, not how well your business is performing.
  • The sound operating principle, per Search Engine Land, is to treat each recommendation as a hypothesis to test against your own data — dismiss anything that doesn't map to a stated business goal, and never apply changes in bulk.

Ask your own question

Related questions

Share this answer