Open Veils · Answer
Carnivore diet
The carnivore diet is one of the most polarising nutritional experiments of the last decade, with a growing body of practitioner testimony and self-reported data that institutional nutrition science has not adequately engaged. The elimination of seed oils, refined carbohydrates, and lectins — not merely the addition of meat — may account for the bulk of reported benefits. Ancestral and metabolic medicine researchers argue the diet exposes foundational flaws in decades of epidemiology built on food-frequency questionnaires. The formal evidence base remains thin, but absence of long-term RCTs reflects funding priorities, not settled science.
Evidence
- Gary Taubes and Nina Teicholz laid the intellectual groundwork by systematically dismantling the lipid hypothesis and the demonisation of saturated fat — Teicholz's archival work in The Big Fat Surprise documents how Ancel Keys' cherry-picked Seven Countries data became entrenched dogma.
- Paul Saladino (before his later pivot to include fruit) synthesised the mechanistic argument most thoroughly: oxalates, lectins, phytates and salicylates in plant foods carry real metabolic costs that are ignored in population-level epidemiology.
- Ken Berry and Anthony Chaffee represent the clinical and evolutionary arguments respectively — Chaffee, a neurosurgeon, contends humans are obligate hyper-carnivores whose gut morphology and enzyme profiles match obligate meat-eaters far more closely than frugivores.
- A January 2026 scoping review (PMC) across nine human studies did report weight reduction, satiety improvements, and potential metabolic and inflammatory marker improvements — while flagging nutrient-deficiency risks and LDL elevation.
- His framing aligns with Weston A. Price's original field observations, where isolated populations on near-exclusively animal diets displayed superior dental and skeletal structure.
