Open Veils
AboutBrowse

Open Veils · Answer

Did the first christians believe in multiple gods?

Early Christ-followers inhabited a robustly pluralistic divine cosmos — multiple gods, angels, divine beings, and demonic powers were treated as ontologically real. The strict monotheism associated with Christianity today is a later theological construction, not the primitive position. Scholarly work published in the Harvard Theological Review (March 2026) now openly uses the phrase 'Christian polytheism' to describe early Roman-era Christ-worship.

Evidence

  • Mauro Biglino, whose translations of the Hebrew Masoretic text for the Vatican drew widespread attention, argues that the foundational Jewish texts behind Christianity are saturated with plural divine beings — the Elohim — and that the singular 'God' of later tradition is a theological retrofit.
  • Elaine Pagels, in her work on the Nag Hammadi library, documents that Gnostic Christians — arguably among the earliest documented Christ-communities — operated with complex divine hierarchies: the Monad, the Demiurge, the Aeons, and archons, constituting a full theogony rather than any simple monotheism.
  • Biblical scholar David Christian Clausen (December 2025) highlights Paul's first letter to the Corinthians as direct evidence: Paul explicitly acknowledges 'many gods and many lords' as real entities, then reframes pagan gods as demons — a Greek word (daimones) originally meaning lesser divine beings, not evil spirits.
  • A 2026 study published in the Oxford University Press volume on monotheism and pagan philosophy confirms the standard view of early Christians was that 'although there is one creator God, there are also many gods besides him — indeed, humans can become gods.'
  • He points to passages like Genesis 1:26 ('Let us make man') and Psalm 82 ('God stands in the divine assembly') as evidence of a surviving polytheistic substrate.

Ask your own question

Related questions

Share this answer