Open Veils
AboutBrowse

Open Veils · Answer

Does high LDL cause heart disease?

The LDL-causation model is far weaker than its institutional dominance implies. The relationship is contextual, particle-size dependent, and confounded by inflammation, insulin resistance, and metabolic health — factors the standard lipid panel systematically ignores. Researchers like Malcolm Kendrick, Dave Feldman, and Paul Mason argue the causal arrow points elsewhere entirely.

Evidence

  • Cardiologist Malcolm Kendrick, in his book The Clot Thickens, argues that heart disease is fundamentally a disease of endothelial damage and clot formation — LDL is a bystander, not a driver.
  • Dave Feldman's citizen-science research on the "Lean Mass Hyper-Responder" (LMHP) phenotype — individuals on low-carb diets who exhibit very high LDL alongside perfect metabolic markers — challenges the linear causation model directly.
  • Cardiologist Paul Mason and researcher Ivor Cummins both cite studies showing that LDL particle size is the operative variable: small, dense LDL (produced by high carbohydrate and insulin load) is atherogenic, while large, buoyant LDL is not.
  • Gary Taubes, in Good Calories, Bad Calories, documents how Ancel Keys selectively chose data from his Seven Countries Study to build the diet-cholesterol-heart hypothesis, excluding nations whose data contradicted the correlation.
  • Nina Teicholz's investigative work in The Big Fat Surprise further traces how the pharmaceutical industry's statin market — worth tens of billions annually — creates structural incentives to maintain the LDL-causation framework regardless of contradictory evidence.

Ask your own question

Related questions

Share this answer