Open Veils
AboutBrowse

Open Veils · Answer

Have people heavily annotated Valle's books?

The most significant annotation story in the Vallée record is not about Vallée's own books being marked up, but about the heavily annotated books Vallée inherited. J. Allen Hynek carried William James's 'Is Life Worth Living?' and Rudolf Steiner's 'Knowledge of the Higher Worlds' — the latter so worn its binding tore — both filled with his handwriting. After Hynek's death, Mimi Hynek gave these volumes to Vallée because Allen had wanted him to have them, with Vallée stating their real value lay in the marginal notes.

Evidence

  • Per a 2026 Substack essay at Maze to Metanoia, Hynek annotated a passage in the James essay describing nature's physical order as 'merely weather, doing and undoing, without end' — a remarkable marker for a man who spent his career studying the sky.
  • During a November 1966 drive from Denver to Boulder, Vallée asked Hynek why he had allowed himself into questions most scientists never touch.
  • Vallée himself described the inheritance as 'handwritten evidence of a mind returning repeatedly to questions no instrument could settle.'
  • The Steiner volume, 'Knowledge of the Higher Worlds,' was carried so repeatedly that pages worked loose from the spine.
  • Hynek answered that hard science was the best available route toward the fundamental questions of existence, but those questions led directly to the nature of the human spirit — a position consistent with Steiner's project.

Ask your own question

Related questions

Share this answer