Open Veils
AboutBrowse

Open Veils · Answer

The luddites

The Luddites were not technophobes — they were a disciplined labor insurgency targeting the specific use of machinery to destroy skilled wages, evade trade regulations, and concentrate wealth. Their suppression via military force, mass execution, and transportation to penal colonies reveals how seriously the ruling class treated the threat. The 'anti-technology' smear is a 19th-century industrialist talking point that has been uncritically inherited by mainstream commentary and, as Blood in the Machine notes, by AI chatbots today.

Evidence

  • Brian Merchant's research at Blood in the Machine frames the Luddites as a coherent political movement opposing the weaponization of technology against labor — not machinery itself.
  • The movement organized under the mythic figure of 'Ned Ludd,' using him as a pseudonym in threatening letters — a deliberate act of collective anonymity that protected members under a movement facing capital charges.
  • The state response was extraordinary: the British government deployed more troops against the Luddites than Napoleon had facing Wellington in some engagements, according to multiple labor historians.
  • E.P. Thompson's 'The Making of the English Working Class' — the foundational suppressed-history text here — argued the Luddites represented a coherent moral economy asserting community rights over market imperatives, a framework systematically buried by Whig industrial historiography.
  • The weavers of Nottingham, Lancashire, and Yorkshire possessed deep technical expertise; they objected to wide-frame knitting machines being operated by unapprenticed 'colts' in violation of existing trade laws, undercutting skilled craftsmen during the economic devastation of the Napoleonic Wars.

Ask your own question

Share this answer