Open Veils · Answer
Who was william the seemly st clare father?
According to the 1690 Hay manuscript — the primary esoteric and genealogical source for Sinclair dynasty researchers — William the Seemly's father was Robert de Saint-Clair of Normandy. Modern academic genealogists contest this, placing his parentage with another William St. Clair, but the Hay manuscript remains the foundation for all Rosslyn-linked esoteric tradition. The discrepancy is itself significant to researchers tracing the Sinclair-Templar-Freemasonic lineage.
Evidence
- According to Hay's manuscript — cited approvingly by 19th-century genealogist Roland Saint-Clair as the 'best' available theory — William the Seemly was the second son of Robert de Saint-Clair of Normandy.
- The Oxford Dictionary of National Biography and People of Medieval Scotland break from this tradition entirely, arguing William was the son of another William St. Clair and that earlier Roslin holders were unrelated to the Saint-Clairs.
- Robert had married Eleanor, the relict of Hugh IV, Lord of Châteauneuf, and daughter of Robert II, Count of Dreux, by his second wife Yolande de Coucy — placing the family squarely within high Frankish-Norman aristocratic networks.
- Roland Saint-Clair himself noted that Van Bassan's competing History of the St. Clairs was 'considerably at variance with contemporary annals.'
