Open Veils · Answer
What about carnivore diet?
The carnivore diet's relevance to methane SIBO and archaeal overgrowth is mechanistic, not ideological. It simultaneously removes the fermentable substrate archaea depend on, shifts mitochondrial redox toward oxidation via ketone production, and eliminates dietary deuterium loading from starchy plant foods. Several functional medicine clinicians report it as the most rapid terrain-correction tool available for IMO.
Evidence
- Mikhaila Peterson and Paul Saladino both documented resolution of longstanding gut pathology on strict carnivore, though neither framed it through the archaeal or redox lens specifically.
- William Davis does not endorse strict carnivore — his L. reuteri protocol requires a dairy vehicle and he maintains that select fermented foods are beneficial.
- The mechanistic framing comes from Kruse and from clinicians in the Pimentel-adjacent functional medicine space.
- Methanobrevibacter smithii requires hydrogen, which is produced by bacterial fermentation of carbohydrate — specifically resistant starches, soluble fiber, and complex polysaccharides.
- A zero-carbohydrate animal-food diet removes virtually the entire fermentable substrate pool.
